Bad Faith Insurance Claims

When Your Insurance Company Doesn’t Play Fair, We Step In.

When you purchase homeowners’ insurance, you enter into a contract built on trust. You pay your premiums. You uphold your responsibilities. And when a disaster strikes, fire, water damage, storm loss, or theft, you expect your insurance company to honor its end of the agreement.

Unfortunately, many property owners quickly discover that insurers are not always eager to pay what a claim is truly worth. Sometimes the delay, denial, or underpayment isn’t just unfair, it’s bad faith.

At Baxter Law Firm, we protect policyholders from abusive insurance practices. If your insurance company is acting in bad faith, we step in immediately to enforce your rights, hold the carrier accountable, and fight for the full compensation you are owed.

What Is a Bad Faith Insurance Claim?

Insurance companies are legally required to treat you fairly, investigate promptly, and handle your claim with honesty and transparency. When they deliberately fail to do so, they may be acting in bad faith.

A bad faith insurance claim arises when the insurance company does not uphold its legal duty to:

  • Properly investigate the loss
  • Pay valid claims in a timely manner
  • Evaluate the damage fairly
  • Communicate honestly with policyholders
  • Follow state regulations and policy language
  • Provide clear explanations for denials or reduced payments

     

Bad faith conduct is more than a simple mistake or misunderstanding. It involves intentional, negligent, or reckless behavior that harms the insured and violates Georgia’s insurance laws.

Common Examples of Bad Faith in Property Claims

Your insurance company ignores your emails, fails to schedule inspections, or constantly asks for documents you’ve already provided. Delay benefits the insurer not you.

The adjuster’s numbers don’t come close to covering the cost to repair your home. Key damages are omitted, materials are downgraded, or labor is undervalued.

You receive a vague or unjustified denial letter or worse, no explanation at all.

The insurer refuses to open walls, ignores secondary damage, or relies on incomplete reports to minimize the scope of repairs.

Insurance policies can be complex and full of jargon. We will break down the terms of your policy, providing clear, actionable advice on how to proceed with your claim for the best possible outcome.

Insurers sometimes push contractors who work in the carrier’s favor, not yours. This can compromise the quality of repairs and limit what the insurer has to pay.

Contents are depreciated unfairly, or ALE (Additional Living Expenses) is cut short without justification.

Georgia law requires carriers to respond within specific timeframes but many violate these deadlines routinely.

If you’ve experienced any of these, your insurance company may be acting in bad faith.

Your Rights Under Georgia Law

Georgia protects policyholders through O.C.G.A. § 33-4-6, which allows insureds to recover:

  • The full amount of the loss
  • Penalties up to 50% of the liability or $5,000 (whichever is greater)
  • Attorney’s fees

But to enforce these rights, you need a law firm that understands how to document bad faith, apply the correct legal standards, and pressure the insurance company to do what they should have done from the beginning.

That’s where we come in.

How Baxter Law Firm Handles Bad Faith Claims

We’ve built a reputation for aggressive representation, strategic case development, and comprehensive claim management. Our team, including attorneys, claim analysts, and an experienced insurance expert, works together to strengthen your case from the moment you hire us.

We Take Over Communication

Once retained, all communication goes through us. No more dealing with adjusters who ignore your calls or misrepresent your loss.

We Reconstruct the Entire Claim File

We review every denial, estimate, photo, vendor invoice, and timeline. We identify delays, inconsistencies, and violations of Georgia law.

We Independently Verify the Damage

With the assistance of our in-house public adjuster and third-party experts, we ensure the full scope of damage is documented not just what the carrier chose to see.

We Identify Bad Faith Conduct Clearly and Concisely

Insurance carriers often bank on homeowners not knowing their rights. We show the carrier exactly where they breached the contract or acted in bad faith and demand correction.

We Build a Legal Strategy That Maximizes the Value of Your Claim

If the carrier refuses to do the right thing, we don’t hesitate. We pursue:

Demand for full payment

Proof of loss enforcement

Appraisal (when appropriate)

Pre-suit negotiation

Litigation for breach of contract and bad faith

We Fight For Penalties and Attorney’s Fees Not Just Your Claim Payment

Bad faith isn’t just about your damage being paid it’s about the insurance company being held accountable for violating the law.

When to Call Us

call us

678-813-1900